Huh, the advisor letter and the application don't seem to fit. The applicant's description of the research seems very early and not very grounded, yet the advisor says that he'll graduate in 2012 and that he's already completed 40 interviews. Based on the application, I didn't give a strong rating.
His support letter suggests that he has already collected interview data, but his abstract does not clearly convey a research design or detailed methodology.
Comments
Really early: a general
Really early: a general framework, but not yet developed and only plans a questionnaire.
Huh, the advisor letter and
Huh, the advisor letter and the application don't seem to fit. The applicant's description of the research seems very early and not very grounded, yet the advisor says that he'll graduate in 2012 and that he's already completed 40 interviews. Based on the application, I didn't give a strong rating.
Not ecewn close to the others
Not ecewn close to the others ...
not ready. no clear sampling
not ready. no clear sampling strategy. no theoretical model is not very strong.
His support letter suggests
His support letter suggests that he has already collected interview data, but his abstract does not clearly convey a research design or detailed methodology.